Casualties of Idol Strategy!
Tonight’s episode of American Idol showed the true & brutal, cut throat reality of the competition… Probably for the first time throughout the entire season so far.
Before I left Los Angeles after my elimination, as well as my confrontation with the Judges/Producers, I said in an interview, “Good luck to the other contestants. Because once you get up there, you get one shot. All the rehearsal & practice means little once you hit that stage & the music starts.” Having been there for Hollywood Week, I found myself amongst some of the most incredibly talented people I had ever met. But in the midst of those genuinely gifted people, were those “over the top” contestants who were obviously there for the sheer entertainment value. After all, it IS a TV show & FOX needs to increase the ratings for it’s 10th season, so that means “increase the crazy & dramatic”. So the job of standing out was a lot harder than what viewers even get to see every Wednesday & Thursday night.
As you’ve seen, some of the “Early Favorites” (as Ryan puts it) lost their chance of progressing in the competition after their performances spiraled out of control. Whether it was a lack of confidence, a moment of doubt and insecurity, or simply nerves getting the best of them, their fate was decided in mere seconds. The unfortunate part of this is knowing the mindset the Judges have when making the cuts: Jennifer Lopez stated in a press conference, “We’re going to be working with the contestants differently this season; giving them more of a chance to prove themselves. We don’t want to send someone, who could’ve been great, home prematurely because of their nerves. And then wonder later on what they could’ve become if we had allowed them to stay.” Hearing such words of grace & seeing the lack of compassion for some contestants almost seems insincere and confusing. Especially after seeing the Judges come their decision after shuffling through a deck of contestant’s pictures. Maybe it’d be better understood if they gave more of a glimpse behind the scenes, into the lives & talents of some of the people America DOESN’T get to see on camera. If they COULD show more than just the same ten contestants each episode, I’m sure they would. But it’s impossible, so America is forced to see what Idol Producers allow them to see. But “Hey! That’s show biz!”
It was comforting to hear the Judge’s comments to those rooms that did not make it through the second Solo Round of Hollywood Week though. Jennifer said to one room, “As performers, we’ve gone to countless auditions where we were told ‘No’, but you keep going! Consistency is key. I may not have made the cut, but I made them a fan!” Even during my confrontation with the Judges, Steven Tyler said to me, “This isn’t the end of the road, Wayne. You took two steps forward & one step back…” So it’s encouraging to see a sense of humanity in the midst of the “glitz & glam” of the American Idol charade.
Nevertheless, its still unfortunate to see so many people, destined for superstardom, sent home because of a moment of weakness. But let’s not forget those who’ve fallen short of the American Idol title in the past: Jennifer Hudson, Daughtry, Clay Aiken, Katharine McPhee, David Archuleta & Kellie Pickler. Like I’ve said before, it may be the road to success for some, but not for everyone. After all, it is a “competition”, so there are bound to be ‘Casualties of Idol Strategy’ for TV entertainment & America’s viewing pleasure.
Thanks for taking the time to read. Much love. - W